Sylvain Peyronnet
  • Member for 11 years, 5 months
  • Last seen more than 9 years ago
Who benefits from this site?
14 votes

I can speak only for myself, but I am exactly the out-of-scope profile that you describe. I am tenured, I just obtained the habilitation thesis meaning that I will apply for professor position in ...

View answer
On the Feasibility of Homework Questions
12 votes

Let think about it as a TCS problem. Most "homework question" are easy to spot, these are the one that are $\epsilon$-far from being at the research level. Then there is a grey zone of "hum, is this ...

View answer
Is "theoretical" computer science too narrow?
11 votes

The question of broadening the scope is indeed a good one. But recall that before thinking for enlarge the scope to CS outside TCS, we should first think about really broadening the scope to TCS ...

View answer
Another go at scope of desirable questions
5 votes

My 2 cents : No question should be deleted except if it is total nonsense (or if it contains questionable content - I mean something that can bring "legal" problems) Making strict rules is not good ...

View answer
Upvoting an answer provided by someone else
3 votes

Maybe it will seem harsh, but in my opinion it is not to the person who asks/answers a question to decide about its reputation, but rather to the community. So, if one has the information that the ...

View answer
Defining the Scope of This Site (or Theory Cafe?)
1 votes

We can just set up a phpbb forum somewhere on the web, and it will be good enough for a TCS cafe (and also for posting job openings, which is another current meta question).

View answer
How will you cite a discussion on this site in your paper?
1 votes

My 2 cents: acknowledge the person in the text and put the reference to the cstheory discussion in a footnote. My wife works in art history, and they proceed this way (however, they reference real ...

View answer